Jessica Ryan is reading spells from her book of the eye when her step aunt, Alex Jett, asks her about the party. Kenzie Reeves, Jessica's new stepdaughter, joins them to show off her costume and to learn that Jessica has decided not to go. Kenzie stomps off and Alex goes to take a shower, leaving Jessica alone with her horniness. Later, Kenzie sneaks into her stepbrother's room and scares him while he's in his boxers. Alex kicks Kenzie out while revealing that he's a virgin and he's expecting to get some tonight. Before he can make it into the shower, Jessica comes in and startles him, causing him to drop his towel and reveal his hardon. Jessica has no shame. She goes right for the gold, sucking down her step nephew's big dick. Kenzie walks in on them and demands to know what Jessica is doing with her virgin. The girls decide they can share.

Next thing Alex knows, he has two hot girls on their knees sharing his hardon and sucking his balls. They even see who can deep throat him the best! The girls decide to relocate to Alex's bedroom with Kenzie leading the way and Jessica following a few steps behind, leading Alex by his fuck stick. Kenzie is surprised to find Haley Spades, Alex's girlfriend, sitting on the bed waiting for him. That's fine because Kenzie is cool to share her virgin as long as she gets a piece of him. She has just started seducing Haley when Jessica and Ryan join them. After the initial moment of surprise, Haley realizes how nice it could be with two extra girls involved. She lets Kenzie and Jessica undress her as they fling off their own clothes.

Kenzie can't wait for Jessica and Haley to be ready to go. She pushes Alex onto his back and climbs on top to start riding him as Jessica reaches out to begin stroking Haley's clit and then bobs her head to feast on Haley's sweet juices. Haley finds herself in the middle next as she eats Kenzie out with Alex fucking her from behind in doggy. Jessica watches the trio for a moment, then climbs up to straddle Kenzie's face and drop down so Kenzie can eat her out. When it's finally Jessica's turn to get some from her step nephew, she lets Alex take her on her back as Haley and Kenzie go for it in a lesbian 69 behind her. Kenzie and Haley eventually reach their own peaks of satisfaction with enough time left to each take one of Jessica's nipples to suck as Alex keeps on banging her. He cums hard, delivering a creampie that the girls lap up to share between themselves.